2009-10
Kristen Heavens, Field Hockey
May Kotsopoulos, Women's Basketball (also America East Scholar-Athlete of the Year)
2008-09
Kim Striegler, Field Hockey
Connor Tobin, Men's Soccer (also America East Scholar-Athlete of the Year)
May Kotsopoulos, Women's Basketball
Kristen Millar, Women's Lacrosse (also America East Scholar-Athlete of the Year)
Joe Serafin, Baseball
2007-08
Carmen Lagala, Women's Indoor Track & Field
Carmen Lagala, Women's Outdoor Track & Field
May Kotsopoulos, Women's Basketball
Connor Tobin, Men's Soccer
2006-07
Martin Klimes, Men's Basketball
2005-06
Merrie-Beth Maynard, Field Hockey
Martin Klimes, Men's Basketball
2004-05
David Hehn, Men's Basketball
Amy Cochran, Women's Soccer
2003-04
David Hehn, Men's Basketball
Kristal Kostiew, Women's Indoor Track and Field
2002-03
Grant Anderson, Men's Basketball
Dawn Cressman, Women's Basketball
Alexis Ressler, Field Hockey
2001-02
George Deane, Men's Outdoor Track and Field
2000-01
Michele Palmer, Women's Cross Country
1999-2000
Chris Shaver, Men's Soccer
Karalyn Church, Women's Basketball
Ashley Couper, Women's Indoor Track and Field
1998-99
Ashley Couper, Women's Cross Country
1997-98
Lori Taylor, Women's Basketball
1995-96
Anna Norgren, Women's Indoor Track and Field
Anna Norgren, Women's Outdoor Track and Field
1992-93
Trond Nystad, Men's Cross Country
1991-92
Steve Johnson, Baseball
Amy Dwire, Women's Indoor Track and Field
Craig Stewart, Men's Lacrosse
1990-91
Trond Nystad, Men's Cross Country
